Here is the mistake behind most genealogy brick walls: the search keeps asking the same question of the same records. The ancestor seems to appear from nowhere in a census, so you search that name in more indexes, then in more spellings, then in more websites. Nothing changes, because the answer is usually in a different kind of record, held under a different name, or attached to a different person entirely.
The 15 strategies below are grouped by what they change: the question, the evidence you already hold, the records you search, and the people you research. Work through them in order and most walls give way somewhere in the first ten.
First, Rewrite the Question You Are Asking
1. Make the goal small and specific
The FamilySearch research process guide warns that a goal like “learn more about my great-grandfather” is too broad. “Find where John Carter was born around 1832” is a question a record can answer. Pick one fact about one person.
2. Write down what you know and where each fact came from
List every date, place and relationship for the ancestor with its source beside it. A written genealogy research plan gives this a home. Facts with no source, or with only a family tree on a website as the source, go in a separate column marked “unproved”. Many walls turn out to rest on one of those.
3. Build a timeline
A year-by-year table of the person’s life shows the gaps. If he is in the 1850 census with a wife but no marriage record, and in an 1860 tax list two counties away, the gaps tell you which records to look for and where.
Then Test the Evidence You Already Hold
4. Re-read every document in full
Go back to the originals, not the index entries. Witnesses on a deed, a neighbour named in a will, an extra child in the household who has a different surname: these details are easy to skip the first time and often matter most.
5. Question the “facts” you inherited
A birth year from a gravestone carved forty years later, a birthplace given by a grandchild on a death certificate, a family story that “the name was changed at Ellis Island”: treat each as a clue to test, not a fact to build on. If you are stuck on the origin of a surname, our guide to finding the origin of your last name explains why spelling and meaning can mislead.
6. Check you have the right person
Two men of the same name, of similar age, in the same county, are common. If the records attached to your ancestor give him two wives at once or a child born when he was nine, you may have merged two people. Separate them on paper by address, occupation and associates before going further.
Search Records You Have Not Tried
7. Search unindexed records
Large parts of the record are still only browsable as images. On FamilySearch, use the catalog for the county and look for deeds, court minutes, tax lists and probate books that show a camera icon but no name index. Browsing a few volumes page by page is slow, and it is where many walls fall.
8. Go to the land and probate records
Deeds often name the previous residence of the buyer (“of Rockbridge County, Virginia”) and record heirs selling inherited land together. Probate files can name every child, including married daughters. Ask the clerk for the whole estate packet, not just the will.
9. Read the local newspaper
Small-town papers printed visits from out-of-town relatives, illness, travel and land sales. One line saying a man’s “brother from Ohio” visited can point to a birthplace no official record gives.
10. Try church, school and society records
Membership transfers in church books often record where a family came from. Lodges, unions and burial societies kept application forms with birthplaces and next of kin.
Research the People Around the Ancestor
11. Use cluster research
The technique often called the FAN club (friends, associates and neighbours) is described in the Wikipedia entry on cluster genealogy: when your ancestor’s own records are silent, research the people around him. Families often migrated together, so a neighbour’s birthplace can reveal your ancestor’s.
12. Note who signed, witnessed and stood surety
Make a list of every name that appears alongside your ancestor’s in deeds, bonds, marriages and baptisms. People who appear twice or more are likely relatives or close associates. Trace two or three of them back a generation.
13. Trace the siblings
Your direct ancestor may have left thin records, while a brother who lived longer, owned more land or applied for a pension left detailed ones. A sibling’s death certificate may name the parents your ancestor’s never did.
14. Use DNA to test a hypothesis
DNA is most useful when you already have a theory. If you think your ancestor was the son of a particular couple, look for matches who descend from that couple’s other children. This overview of turning DNA results into real family stories shows how matches and trees fit together.
Step Back When Nothing Works
15. Get fresh eyes
Write a one-page summary of the problem: the question, what you know with sources, and what you have searched with dates. The act of writing it often shows the gap. Then share it with a county genealogy society, an online forum for that region, or a friend who has never seen the problem. People who know the local records well can name a source you did not know existed.
A Quick Self-Check Before You Call It Impossible
| Have you… | If not, try |
|---|---|
| Searched every census year the person could appear in? | Page-by-page browsing of the right district |
| Checked land, tax and court records for each county? | The FamilySearch catalog for each county |
| Traced at least two siblings? | Their death records and obituaries |
| Listed the neighbours and witnesses? | Researching two of them back a generation |
| Searched for boundary changes? | The parent county’s records for earlier years |
| Recorded what you searched and found nothing in? | A research log, so you stop repeating searches |
Some questions do not have a surviving answer. Courthouses burned, churches lost books and some people never appeared in a written record. Even then, a well-documented “not found” is useful: it saves the next researcher, often a descendant, from repeating the same months of work. The general habits of good self-directed research, set out in this beginner method for researching a topic on your own, apply just as well to a stubborn ancestor.
Frequently Asked Questions
What counts as a brick wall in genealogy?
It is the point in a family line where you cannot find the next generation back, usually because the obvious records do not name parents or a birthplace. It is not the same as a lost record. Many brick walls are solved by records you have not yet tried, or by realising the evidence you hold points to a different person.
How long should I spend on a brick wall before moving on?
Set a time box, such as four research sessions, then switch to another line and come back later. New collections are digitised and indexed constantly, and returning after a few months with fresh eyes often helps. Keep a research log so that when you return, you know exactly what has already been searched.
Can DNA testing break a brick wall on its own?
Rarely on its own. DNA matches show that you are related to someone, but you need trees and records to work out how. It works best as a test of a specific theory, such as whether your ancestor belonged to a particular family, by checking whether descendants of that family appear among your matches.
Should I hire a professional genealogist?
Consider it when the problem depends on local records you cannot reach, or on old handwriting or a language you do not read. Prepare a clear summary of the question and your previous searches first. That keeps costs down and lets the researcher start where you stopped rather than repeating your work.