What to Do When Someone Becomes Emotional During an Interview

You sit at the kitchen table with a parent, recorder humming, and a photograph is placed between you. A story about a wartime loss begins, then the voice falters and tears appear. The moment is a reminder that family‑history interviews often surface strong feelings, and how you respond can affect both the completeness of the record and the comfort of the interviewee.

Purpose of the technique

The technique addresses the inevitable emotional spikes that arise when personal memories are revisited. In family‑history work, a single unrecorded detail can be a missing link for future generations, so allowing the interviewee to process feelings without cutting them off preserves the depth of the narrative. It also builds trust, showing that the interview is a safe space rather than a rapid fact‑gathering exercise. By handling emotion thoughtfully, the recorder captures both the facts and the tone that give those facts meaning.

Preparation before you begin

Before the recorder clicks, spend a few minutes visualising the interview flow. Decide which topics are likely to be sensitive and plan gentle transitions. Choose a quiet, comfortable room with easy access to water, tissues, and a chair that can be moved for a short break. Review consent forms and remind yourself that any medical or legal questions must be deferred to a professional. Finally, write a short list of open‑ended prompts that can be paused or re‑phrased if emotion rises.

Step‑by‑step response

When the interviewee becomes emotional, follow these actions in order: 1. Stop the recording momentarily and place the device on mute. 2. Offer a simple acknowledgement such as, “I see this is hard for you.” 3. Give them a few breaths; do not fill the silence with your own story. 4. Ask if they would like a pause, a glass of water, or a moment to collect thoughts. 5. If they choose to continue, resume recording at a slower pace, allowing longer pauses between questions. 6. If they need a longer break, suggest a short walk or a return later in the day.

Copyable script

You can keep this wording handy: “I notice this part brings up strong feelings. Take all the time you need; we can pause, sip water, or continue whenever you feel ready. Your story matters, and I’m here to listen, not to rush.”

If the first approach fails

Sometimes the interviewee will remain silent or give a brief answer without elaboration. First, check whether they are unwilling to share or simply need more time. A gentle follow‑up like, “Would you prefer to talk about something else for now?” can clarify. For older or frail participants, reduce question length, sit at eye level, and keep the recorder at a comfortable distance. Reticent people may respond better to written prompts or a photo cue before speaking. If emotion persists, offer to end the session and schedule a later date, noting the topic for future follow‑up.

Immediate note‑taking

Right after the recorder is turned off, write a brief entry that captures the emotional cue, the exact question asked, and any partial answer given. Note the interviewee’s body language, the duration of the pause, and whether a break was taken. Record any follow‑up actions you promised, such as sending a copy of the photograph or arranging a later session. This log helps you track which topics may need revisiting and ensures that the emotional context is preserved alongside the factual content.

Worth remembering: When emotion appears, pause, acknowledge, and offer a break before resuming; this simple pattern keeps the interviewee comfortable and the story intact.

Common questions

What is the simplest way to start?

Begin with a calm, open‑ended prompt such as, “Can you tell me about your childhood home?” and let the interviewee set the pace without rushing to the next question.

What mistakes should I avoid?

Do not try to fix the feeling, rush through the story, or ignore signs of distress. Avoid leading questions that pressure the interviewee to reveal more than they are ready to share.

How do I know when the project is finished?

The project concludes when the interviewee feels they have shared the desired memories and no longer exhibits strong emotional distress, and when you have documented the agreed‑upon topics in your notes.