What Happened to the 1890 Census and How to Fill the Gap

The 1890 census was not simply lost in a fire. The blaze in the Commerce Department building on 10 January 1921 destroyed part of it and soaked much of the rest, but a large share survived damaged. Those surviving schedules were then authorised for disposal by Congress in 1933 and destroyed in the following years. What remains today covers just over 6,000 people.

For family historians that leaves a twenty-year gap between the 1880 and 1900 censuses, a period of heavy immigration, westward moves and marriages. This guide explains what happened, what survives, and a checklist of substitutes that can fill the gap for your own family.

What Actually Happened, Year by Year

Date Event
1890 The census is taken, with a separate schedule for each family for the first time
10 January 1921 Fire in the Commerce Department building in Washington, DC
1921 Damaged records moved to temporary storage, then back to the census building
December 1932 The Census Bureau lists the 1890 schedules for destruction
21 February 1933 Congress authorises their destruction
About 1934 to 1935 The remaining schedules are destroyed

The National Archives journal Prologue tells the full story in its article “First in the Path of the Firemen”. The Census Director at the time estimated that a quarter of the 1890 schedules were destroyed outright and half of the rest damaged; later estimates put the destruction at 15 to 25 percent. There was no national archives building to receive the damaged volumes, and in the end they were disposed of. The National Archives itself was created in 1934, too late for them.

Why the loss hurts

The 1890 count asked questions earlier censuses had not: the number of children a married woman had borne and how many were living, year of immigration, naturalization, ability to speak English, home ownership, and Civil War service. For families who arrived in the 1880s, it would have been the first census to record them.

What Survives

The National Archives page on the 1890 census lists the survivors:

  • Population fragments: over 6,160 people from parts of Alabama, Georgia, Illinois, Minnesota, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, South Dakota, Texas and the District of Columbia. If your family lived in one of those places, check the index anyway; the odds are low, but the search is free.
  • Special schedules of Union veterans and widows: these survive for part of Kentucky through Wyoming in alphabetical order, plus some navy vessels and yards and a few scattered schedules for earlier states. They list each veteran (or his widow), rank, unit, enlistment and discharge dates, post office address and any disability.
  • Oklahoma territorial census of 1890, taken separately.
  • A few smaller lists, such as selected lists of African Americans in Delaware.

The veterans schedule is the most useful survivor. Enumerators sometimes listed Confederate veterans and men from earlier wars too, so check even if your ancestor did not serve the Union.

Substitutes Checklist: Fill the Twenty-Year Gap

No single record replaces a census. Several together usually do. Work through these for the place where your family lived:

Bracket with the censuses either side

  • 1880 federal census: everyone in the household, with relationships.
  • 1900 federal census: month and year of birth, years married, children born and living, year of immigration. Many of the 1890 questions are answered here, ten years late. Our column-by-column guide to reading an old US census record explains each one.

State and local counts

  • State censuses. Several states took their own censuses between federal counts. Check whether yours did, and for which years, in the FamilySearch Research Wiki or the state archives.
  • School censuses listing children by household.

Lists of residents

  • City directories: annual for many towns, naming the head of household, address and often occupation. A run of directories traces a family year by year through the gap.
  • Voter registers and poll books.
  • Tax lists for property and personal tax.

Life events

  • Church records: baptisms, marriages, burials, membership rolls.
  • Civil birth, marriage and death records, where the state kept them.
  • Newspapers: local news columns, obituaries, court reports.
  • Naturalization papers for immigrants who became citizens in the 1890s.
  • Land records and homestead files for families moving west.

Military

  • The 1890 veterans schedule (above).
  • Union pension files, many filed in the 1890s after the 1890 Disability Act widened eligibility.

A Worked Example: Tracing a Family Across the Gap

This is an invented illustration. In 1880 the Novak family is in Cleveland: Jan, Anna and two children. In 1900 they are in Chicago with seven children, the eldest two missing.

  1. City directories show Jan Novak in Cleveland through 1886, then in Chicago from 1888.
  2. The 1900 census says Anna has had nine children, seven living, so two died. That sends you to death and burial records in both cities.
  3. Church baptisms in Chicago between 1888 and 1899 name the younger children and their godparents.
  4. A marriage record from 1897 finds the eldest daughter, explaining her absence.

Four record types rebuild what the census would have told you, and add details it never asked.

Keep Your Substitute Sources Organised

Substitutes are scattered across many websites. Make a folder of bookmarks for each place your family lived: the state archives, the directory collection, the church records and the newspaper site. This plain-English guide to saving websites with browser bookmarks covers folders, which keeps a long substitutes search from turning into thirty open tabs.

Then write down which sources you checked, for which years, and what you found or did not find. A plan stops you repeating searches; our guide to building a genealogy research plan shows a simple format.

For the decades after the gap, the free name search covered in our guide to searching the 1940 census picks up the family again.

Start with the 1900 census for the answers the 1890 count would have given, then use directories and church records to walk the family back through the missing decade.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did the 1921 fire destroy the whole 1890 census?

No. Estimates at the time put outright destruction at about a quarter of the schedules, and later estimates at 15 to 25 percent, with much of the rest damaged by water and smoke. The damaged remainder was authorised for destruction by Congress in 1933 and destroyed in the mid-1930s. Only fragments survive.

Can I search the surviving 1890 census fragments online?

Yes. The surviving population fragments, covering just over 6,160 people, and the special schedules of Union veterans and widows are indexed by major genealogy websites, including free ones. The National Archives page on the 1890 census lists the microfilm publications if you want to browse the images directly.

Is there a 1890 census for Oklahoma?

A separate 1890 territorial census of Oklahoma survives and is held by the National Archives. It is distinct from the federal population schedules, most of which were lost. If your family was in Oklahoma Territory in 1890, it is well worth searching.

What is the best single substitute for the 1890 census?

For most families, a combination of the 1900 census and city directories comes closest. The 1900 census answers many of the same questions, including years married and children born, while directories place the family year by year. In rural areas, tax lists and church records often do the job directories do in towns.