Which DNA Test Is Best for Genealogy? Match It to Your Goal

The best DNA test for genealogy is the one whose database holds the relatives you are looking for. For most people researching American family lines, that means the company with the largest match list. For a direct male line, it means a Y-DNA test that only one major company sells. And for anyone uneasy about where genetic data ends up, the right choice depends as much on who owns the company and how you can delete your data as on price.

Below, the main companies are compared on the things that matter for family history, followed by a goal-by-goal recommendation, the privacy steps to take on day one, and a note on why one test may not be enough.

Start With Your Goal, Not the Brand

Your goal Test type Where to look first
Find cousins and break through recent brick walls Autosomal The largest database
Trace a surname through the direct paternal line Y-DNA (men only) FamilyTreeDNA
Trace the direct maternal line mtDNA FamilyTreeDNA
Find matches in Europe or outside the US Autosomal A company with a strong overseas customer base, plus uploads
Identify an unknown parent Autosomal Test at the largest database, then upload elsewhere

Autosomal tests read DNA inherited from both parents and find cousins on every line back several generations. Y-DNA and mtDNA follow one line each, much further back, but say nothing about your other ancestors.

The Main Companies, Side by Side

AncestryDNA

The largest consumer DNA network. Its 2023 description, as reported in Wikipedia’s article on Ancestry, was more than 25 million people. It is owned by the private equity firm Blackstone, which bought Ancestry in December 2020. Its strength for genealogy is the combination of a huge match list with a large collection of user family trees, which makes it easier to see how a match connects to you.

MyHeritage DNA

According to the Wikipedia article on MyHeritage, the company had more than 6.5 million DNA kits in its database by March 2023, and it accepts DNA files uploaded from other companies. It has been owned by Francisco Partners since 2021. It is often recommended for people with European roots because of its international customer base. In 2018 it disclosed a breach of email addresses and hashed passwords from 2017; the company said DNA data was stored separately and not affected.

23andMe

Known for health reports as well as ancestry. It had genotyped more than 14 million people by February 2024. The Wikipedia article on 23andMe records that in October 2023 attackers used reused passwords to reach data on about 6.9 million users through the DNA Relatives feature, that the company filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in March 2025, and that the sale to TTAM Research Institute, a nonprofit led by the co-founder Anne Wojcicki, completed on July 14, 2025, for $305 million. If you tested there, review your settings under the new owner.

FamilyTreeDNA

The specialist. FamilyTreeDNA’s own site says more than 2 million people have tested with it, and it sells Family Finder (autosomal), Y-DNA tests from Y-37 up to Big Y-700, and mtDNA tests. It is the main place to compare Y-DNA results with other men of the same surname through surname projects.

What “Best” Means for Family History

  • Database size. More testers means more matches. This matters more than any other feature for cousin research.
  • Linked family trees. Matches with trees attached are far more useful than matches with names only.
  • Tools. Shared-match lists, segment details and the option to download your raw data.
  • Uploads. Whether you can transfer raw data in from another company to reach a second database without paying for a second kit.
  • Privacy and ownership. Who owns the company now, whether law enforcement can search the database, and how to delete your data.

Ethnicity estimates are the least useful part of any test for genealogy. They are broad, they change as the reference panels change, and they rarely solve a research question. Choose on matches, not on the pie chart.

One Test or Two? A Simple Plan

  1. Test at the largest autosomal database first. That gives you the most matches for the price.
  2. Download your raw data file. Store it somewhere safe.
  3. Upload it to services that accept transfers, such as MyHeritage, to reach a second pool of cousins at low or no cost.
  4. Add a Y-DNA test only if a direct paternal surname question needs it, and test the oldest living man in that line.

Older relatives are the priority. A grandparent’s test reaches a generation further back than yours, and their matches are not diluted by the other side of your family. If you are buying a kit as a present, our guide on gifts for family history enthusiasts covers alternatives that suit people who would rather not test.

Privacy Steps to Take on Day One

  • Use a unique password and turn on two-step sign-in. The 23andMe incident began with passwords reused from other sites. This plain guide to setting up two-factor authentication walks through it.
  • Decide whether you want to appear in the match list and under what display name.
  • Read the research consent option separately from the matching option. They are not the same thing.
  • Find the data deletion page and note how it works before you need it.
  • Talk to close relatives first. A test can reveal unexpected parentage, which affects them as much as you.

Once results arrive, our guide to making sense of DNA ancestry results explains the first things to do with a match list.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which DNA test has the most people in its database?

AncestryDNA, which described a network of more than 25 million users in 2023. 23andMe had genotyped more than 14 million by early 2024, MyHeritage reported more than 6.5 million kits by March 2023, and FamilyTreeDNA says more than 2 million people have tested with it. Companies count differently, so treat these as rough comparisons.

Is Ancestry or MyHeritage better for genealogy?

For American lines, AncestryDNA usually produces more matches because its database is much larger. MyHeritage is often stronger for European matches and accepts uploads from other companies, so many researchers test with Ancestry and upload the raw data to MyHeritage. That way you search both pools while paying for one kit.

Do I need a Y-DNA test to trace my surname?

Only if your question is about the direct paternal line, father to father to father. A Y-DNA test, taken by a man who carries the surname, compares him with other men in surname projects. Women cannot take it themselves but can ask a brother, father, uncle or male cousin from that line to test.

What happened to 23andMe customer data after the bankruptcy?

The company filed for bankruptcy in March 2025, and its assets were sold to TTAM Research Institute, a nonprofit led by co-founder Anne Wojcicki, with the sale completing in July 2025. Customers who tested there should sign in, review privacy and research consent settings, and decide whether to download or delete their data.